Mistakes Were Made

Make fun of the Germans all you want, and Iâve certainly done that a bit during these past few years, but, if thereâs one thing theyâre exceptionally good at, itâs taking responsibility for their mistakes.
Seriously, when it comes to acknowledging oneâs mistakes, and not rationalizing, or minimizing, or attempting to deny them, and any discomfort they may have allegedly caused, no one does it quite like the Germans.
Take this Covid mess, for example. Just last week, the German authorities confessed that they made a few minor mistakes during their management of the âCovid pandemic.â According to Karl Lauterbach, the Minister of Health, âwe were sometimes too strict with the children and probably started easing the restrictions a little too late.â
Horst Seehofer, the former Interior Minister, admitted that he would no longer agree to some of the Covid restrictions today, for example, nationwide nighttime curfews. âOne must be very careful with calls for compulsory vaccination,â he added. Helge Braun, Head of the Chancellery and Minister for Special Affairs under Merkel, agreed that there had been âmisjudgments,â for example, âoverestimating the effectiveness of the vaccines.â
This display of the German authoritiesâ unwavering commitment to transparency and honesty, and the principle of personal honor that guides the German authorities in all their affairs, and that is deeply ingrained in the German character, was published in a piece called âThe Divisive Virusâ in Der Spiegel, and immediately widely disseminated by the rest of the German state and corporate media in a totally organic manner which did not in any way resemble one enormous Goebbelsian keyboard instrument pumping out official propaganda in perfect synchronization, or anything creepy and fascistic like that.
Germany, after all, is âan extremely democratic state,â with freedom of speech and the press and all that, not some kind of totalitarian country where the masses are inundated with official propaganda and critics of the government are dragged into criminal court and prosecuted on trumped-up âhate crimeâ charges.
OK, sure, in a non-democratic totalitarian system, such public âadmissions of mistakesâ â and the synchronized dissemination thereof by the media â would just be a part of the process of whitewashing the authoritiesâ fascistic behavior during some particularly totalitarian phase of transforming society into whatever totalitarian dystopia they were trying to transform it into (for example, a three-year-long âstate of emergency,â which they declared to keep the masses terrorized and cooperative while they stripped them of their democratic rights, i.e., the ones they hadnât already stripped them of, and conditioned them to mindlessly follow orders, and robotically repeat nonsensical official slogans, and vent their impotent hatred and fear at the new âUntermenschenâ or âcounter-revolutionariesâ), but that is obviously not the case here.
No, this is definitely not the German authorities staging a public âaccountabilityâ spectacle in order to memory-hole what happened during 2020-2023 and enshrine the official narrative in history. Thereâs going to be a formal âInquiry Commissionâ â conducted by the same German authorities that managed the âcrisisâ â which will get to the bottom of all the regrettable but completely understandable âmistakesâ that were made in the heat of the heroic battle against The Divisive Virus!
OK, calm down, all you âconspiracy theorists,â âCovid deniers,â and âanti-vaxxers.â This isnât going to be like the Nuremberg Trials. No one is going to get taken out and hanged. Itâs about identifying and acknowledging mistakes, and learning from them, so that the authorities can manage everything better during the next âpandemic,â or âclimate emergency,â or âterrorist attack,â or âinsurrection,â or whatever.
For example, the Inquiry Commission will want to look into how the government accidentally declared a Nationwide State of Pandemic Emergency and revised the Infection Protection Act, suspending the German constitution and granting the government the power to rule by decree, on account of a respiratory virus that clearly posed no threat to society at large, and then unleashed police goon squads on the thousands of people who gathered outside the Reichstag to protest the revocation of their constitutional rights.
Once they do, Iâm sure theyâll find that that âmistakeâ bears absolutely no resemblance to the Enabling Act of 1933, which suspended the German constitution and granted the government the power to rule by decree, after the Nazis declared a nationwide âstate of emergency.â
Another thing the Commission will probably want to look into is how the German authorities accidentally banned any further demonstrations against their arbitrary decrees, and ordered the police to brutalize anyone participating in such âillegal demonstrations.â
And, while the Commission is inquiring into the possibly slightly inappropriate behavior of their law enforcement officials, they might want to also take a look at the behavior of their unofficial goon squads, like Antifa, which they accidentally encouraged to attack the âanti-vaxxers,â the âCovid deniers,â and anyone brandishing a copy of the German constitution.
Come to think of it, the Inquiry Commission might also want to look into how the German authorities, and the overwhelming majority of the state and corporate media, accidentally systematically fomented mass hatred of anyone who dared to question the governmentâs arbitrary and nonsensical decrees or who refused to submit to âvaccination,â and publicly demonized us as âCorona deniers,â âconspiracy theorists,â âanti-vaxxers,â âfar-right anti-Semites,â etc., to the point where mainstream German celebrities like Sarah Bosetti were literally describing us as the inessential âappendixâ in the body of the nation, quoting an infamous Nazi almost verbatim.

And then thereâs the whole âvaccinationâ business. The Commission will certainly want to inquire into that. They will probably want to start their inquiry with Karl Lauterbach, and determine exactly how he accidentally lied to the public, over and over, and over againâŠ
And whipped people up into a mass hysteria over âKILLER VARIANTSââŠ

And âLONG COVID BRAIN ATTACKSâ âŠ

And how âTHE UNVACCINATED ARE HOLDING THE WHOLE COUNTRY HOSTAGE, SO WE NEED TO FORCIBLY VACCINATE EVERYONE!â

And so on. I could go on with this all day, but it will be much easier to just refer you, and the Commission, to this documentary film by Aya VelĂĄzquez. Non-German readers may want to skip to the second half, unless theyâre interested in the German âCorona Expert CouncilââŠ
Look, the point is, everybody makes âmistakes,â especially during a âstate of emergency,â or a war, or some other type of global âcrisis.â At least we can always count on the Germans to step up and take responsibility for theirs, and not claim that they didnât know what was happening, or that they were âjust following orders,â or that âthe science changed.â
Plus, all this Covid stuff is ancient history, and, as Olaf, an editor at Der Spiegel, reminds us, itâs time to put the âThe Divisive Pandemicâ behind usâŠ

âŠand click heels, and heil the New Normal Democracy!
CJ Hopkins is an award-winning American playwright, novelist and political satirist based in Berlin. His plays are published by Bloomsbury Publishing and Broadway Play Publishing, Inc. His dystopian novel, Zone 23, is published by Snoggsworthy, Swaine & Cormorant. Volumes I and II of his Consent Factory Essays are published by Consent Factory Publishing, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Amalgamated Content, Inc. He can be reached at cjhopkins.com or consentfactory.org.
SUPPORT OFFGUARDIAN
If you enjoy OffG's content, please help us make our monthly fund-raising goal and keep the site alive.
For other ways to donate, including direct-transfer bank details click HERE.
No comments:
Post a Comment